"Tolkien would have LOVED it!" or would he? Let's bring him back, give him a screening, and listen to what he has to say:

Click icon for comment

The Fellowship of the Ring. First scene:

The Fellowship of the Ring. Next scene:

The Fellowship of the Ring. Next scene:

The Fellowship of the Ring. Next scene:

The Two Towers. Next scene:

The Two Towers. Next scene:

The Two Towers. Next scene:

The Two Towers. Next scene:

The Two Towers. Next scene:

The Two Towers. Next scene:

The Return of the King. Next scene:

The Return of the King. Next scene:

The Return of the King. Next scene:

The Return of the King. Next scene:

The Return of the King. Next scene:

The Return of the King. Next scene:

The Return of the King. Next scene:

Ars longa, temper brevis.

Many shocked fans were glad to hear they eventually made up, as we saw here: