The Silmarillion - Chapters 19-24

November 19, 2001 - January 25, 2002

This is the First Discussion - click at right to view the Second, Third, and Fourth Discussions.

Unfortunately, in 2016 the TORn servers began redirecting all hyperlinks to the 'Old Boards' to the current discussion boards. The 'grayed-out' links will be updated if the archival links are ever restored.

Home    Previous: Chapters 12-18  Next: Akallabeth; Of The Rings of Power and the Third Age

 

19. Of Beren and Lúthien

by Daddy Twofoot, November 19-December 2, 2001

FYI: I will start Chapter 19 Monday evening (EST) [11/19/2001 @ 2:50] (10/10)

"...it was a wraith of Gorlim" [11/19/2001 @ 21:05] (2/18)

Parallels [11/21/2001 @ 1:33] (5/21)

"...doom...shall send him..." [11/21/2001 @ 1:54] (1/9)

"For little price do Elven-kings sell their daughters" [11/24/2001 @ 15:57] (5/9)

Dueling Oaths [11/24/2001 @ 17:35] (1/6)

Elven "Magic" [11/25/2001 @ 16:44] (3/11)

The Power of Song [11/25/2001 @ 16:50] (4/6)

Betrayal [11/29/2001 @ 4:53] (6/21)

Good dog! [11/29/2001 @ 5:01] (7/17)

"Then Sauron yielded himself..." [12/2/2001 @ 15:33] (2/3)

"You must choose, Beren..." [12/2/2001 @ 15:51] (2/2)

Battle with Morgoth [12/2/2001 @ 16:15] (1/6)

The Quest Fulfilled [12/2/2001 @ 16:17] (1/2)

Luthien's Choice [12/2/2001 @ 16:19] (2/2)

Summary (long) [12/2/2001 @ 16:37] (10/13)

See the 2nd Discussion by NZ Strider (1st half) and drogo_drogo (2nd half), October-November 2004

See the 3rd Discussion by Hamfast Gamgee (1st half) and Beren IV (2nd half), November 2009

See the 4th Discussion by Macliel, May 2013

 

20. Of the Fifth Battle: Ninaeth Arnoediad

by Karmul, December 7-8, 2001

#1: Of the Fifth Battle: Nirnaeth Arnoediad <Eledhwen> [12/7/2001 @ 15:17] (3/7)

#2: Thingol and the Silmaril <Eledhwen> [12/7/2001 @ 15:22] (3/4)

#3: Hope in a black dawn <Eledhwen> [12/7/2001 @ 15:29] (1/2)

#4 The army of the west. [12/7/2001 @ 20:14] (1/4)

#5 Morgoth's plans [12/7/2001 @ 20:30] (2/3)

#6 The unfolding of the Union begins. [12/7/2001 @ 21:02] (2/4)

#7 Nirnaeth Arnoediad, Unumbered Tears. [12/7/2001 @ 21:37] (3/9)

#8 Morgoths last host issues forth [12/7/2001 @ 22:34] (1/2)

#9 The stand of the Naugrim. [12/7/2001 @ 23:16] (3/6)

#10 The Death of Fingon [12/8/2001 @ 0:03] (1/5)

#11 Capture of Hurin [12/8/2001 @ 18:39] (4/5)

#12 Morgoths Victory [12/8/2001 @ 19:14] (1/1)

#13 The Fall of the Falas, and seven ships sail to the West [12/8/2001 @ 19:45] (1/1)

#14 And Morgoth dwells on Turgon [12/8/2001 @ 21:40] (1/1)

#15 Hurin is brought before Morgoth [12/8/2001 @ 22:01] (2/4)

#16 The Hill of Tears [12/8/2001 @ 22:30] (3/3)

See the 2nd Discussion by N.E. Brigand, November 2004

See the 3rd Discussion by sador, Nov-Dec 2009

See the 4th Discussion by Brethil, May 2013

 

21. Of Túrin Turambar

by Eledhwen, December 9-18, 2001

Of Túrin Turambar [12/9/2001 @ 17:16] (5/5)

#2: Túrin in Doriath [12/9/2001 @ 17:17] (3/4)

#3: Neithan [12/9/2001 @ 17:18] (3/8)

#4: Beleg returns to Doriath [12/11/2001 @ 6:48] (2/3)

#5: Mîm [12/11/2001 @ 6:58] (2/2)

#5: In Bar-en-Danwedh [12/11/2001 @ 7:04] (2/2)

#7: Morgoth is plotting [12/12/2001 @ 5:43] (2/2)

#8: betrayal and capture [12/12/2001 @ 5:44] (2/4)

#9: Tragedy strikes [12/12/2001 @ 6:04] (3/4)

#10: Beleg's burial [12/13/2001 @ 6:39] (1/2)

#11: Nargothrond [12/13/2001 @ 6:59] (1/2)

#12: Dark tidings from the Havens [12/14/2001 @ 10:42] (1/3)

#13: Glaurung [12/14/2001 @ 10:43] (1/1)

#14: Returning home [12/15/2001 @ 12:47] (1/1)

#15: Haudh-en-Elleth [12/15/2001 @ 12:55] (1/2)

#17: Morwen and Nienor [12/17/2001 @ 7:00] (1/1)

#17a: Níniel [12/17/2001 @ 7:07] (1/4)

#18: the return of Glaurung [12/17/2001 @ 7:14] (2/4)

#19: The Slaying of Glaurung [12/18/2001 @ 6:49] (1/1)

#20: The Death of Nienor-Níniel [12/18/2001 @ 6:59] (1/1)

#21: The Death of Túrin [12/18/2001 @ 7:10] (2/2)

summing up [12/18/2001 @ 7:16] (3/4)

See the 2nd Discussion by Menelwyn (part 1) and Tharangil (part 2), November 2004

See the 3rd Discussion by Nix of Mirkwood (part 1) and Boromir's bane (part 2), December 2009

See the 4th Discussion by telain, May 2013

 

22. Of the Ruin of Doriath

by FingonOfPittsburgh, January 7-11, 2002

#1 -- The Last Days of Hurin Thalion. [1/7/2002 @ 14:14] (4/10)

#2 -- The Curse of Morgoth Bauglir. [1/7/2002 @ 14:22] (3/5)

#3 -- Hurin in Nargothrond [1/8/2002 @ 9:59] (2/7)

#4 -- Hurin in Menegroth [1/9/2002 @ 11:04] (5/6)

Re: Sil Discussion #3-- Ainagil, look here. Curse of Morgoth vs Doom of Mandos <Inferno> [1/9/2002 @ 12:01] (1/4)

#5 -- The Nauglamir and the Silmaril [1/9/2002 @ 13:05] (3/12)

#6 -- "...and they were filled with a great lust..." [1/10/2002 @ 9:52] (3/4)

#7 -- The Passing of Elwe Singollo [1/10/2002 @ 10:03] (8/13)

hey, Inferno, in response to your post <Ainagil> [1/10/2002 @ 17:16] (0/0)

#8 -- "there came forth the Shepherds of the Trees" [1/10/2002 @ 18:36] (3/8)

#9 -- "Then Beren gazed in wonder" [1/10/2002 @ 18:59] (2/10)

#10 -- A bridge to the past? [1/10/2002 @ 21:39] (4/13)

#11 -- "They came at unawares in the middle of winter..." [1/11/2002 @ 9:18] (3/9)

Summary [1/11/2002 @ 11:11] (7/8)

See the 2nd Discussion by Entwife Wandlimb, November-December 2004

See the 3rd Discussion by batik, January 2010

See the 4th Discussion by Faenoriel, July 2013

 

23. Of Tuor and the Fall of Gondolin

by Inferno, January 16-19, 2002

Family Lines [1/16/2002 @ 13:42] (3/3)

Tuor and the Elves [1/16/2002 @ 13:50] (5/22)

In the name of Love [1/16/2002 @ 13:52] (6/6)

Ulmo. [1/17/2002 @ 14:00] (3/3)

Turgon's Pride [1/17/2002 @ 14:04] (4/4)

Turin's Cameo [1/17/2002 @ 14:07] (4/5)

Tuor and Idril [1/17/2002 @ 14:12] (4/5)

Maeglin's Treachery [1/18/2002 @ 13:16] (4/5)

Playing 'What if?' [1/18/2002 @ 13:19] (2/2)

The Fall of Gondolin [1/18/2002 @ 13:26] (3/8)

Let me 'splain. No, that would take to long, let me sum up. [1/19/2002 @ 14:36] (7/9)

See the 2nd Discussion by snowdropper, December 2004

See the 3rd Discussion by Hamfast Gamgee, January 2010

See the 4th Discussion by Macliel, August 2013

 

24. Of the Voyage of Eärendil and the War of Wrath

by Idril Celebrindal, January 22-25, 2002

Bright Earendil [1/22/2002 @ 10:53] (5/10)

Bilbo's poem of Eärendil [1/22/2002 @ 11:05] (3/5)

The refugees of Sirion [1/22/2002 @ 11:10] (2/4)

The Oath of Feanor [1/23/2002 @ 11:12] (4/8)

Elrond and Elros [1/23/2002 @ 11:18] (3/8)

Elwing and Ulmo [1/23/2002 @ 11:26] (6/12)

The Blessed Land [1/24/2002 @ 11:10] (5/6)

"Here none but myself shall set foot..." [1/24/2002 @ 11:31] (2/3)

The policies of the Valar [1/24/2002 @ 11:50] (3/15)

Gil-Estel, the star of high hope [1/24/2002 @ 11:57] (6/12)

The War of Wrath [1/25/2002 @ 11:51] (5/11)

The intervention of the Valar [1/25/2002 @ 11:55] (1/3)

The fate of the Silmarils [1/25/2002 @ 12:08] (6/6)

The ones who remained [1/25/2002 @ 12:17] (3/10)

Summary [1/25/2002 @ 12:54] (10/10)

See the 2nd Discussion by Altaira and drogo_drogo, December 2004

See the 3rd Discussion by Saelind, January 2010

See the 4th Discussion by Ardamire, August 2013

Home    Previous: Chapters 12-18  Next: Akallabeth; Of The Rings of Power and the Third Age