The Hobbit - Chapters XVIII - XIX

June 14, 2004 - July 1, 2004

This is the First Discussion - click at right to view the Second and Third Discussions.

Unfortunately, in 2016 the TORn servers began redirecting all hyperlinks to the 'Old Boards' to the current discussion boards. The 'grayed-out' links will be updated if the archival links are ever restored.

Home    Previous: Chapters XV-XVII

 

XVIII. The Return Journey

by Altaira and notlost, June 14-20, 2004

<Altaira>

#1: The Sounds of Silence [6/14 @ 0:28] (10/14)

Addition <Beren IV> [6/14 @ 0:58] (4/18)

#2: The Passing of Thorin Oakenshield [6/14 @ 21:06] (8/10)

#3: Bilbo Wept [6/14 @ 23:34] (5/17)

#4: The Recounting [6/15 @ 10:50] (1/1)

#5: The Eagles Have Landed (And I Missed It!) [6/15 @ 22:43] (4/4)

<notlost>

#6: The Final Resting Place (she’s ba-ack!) [6/16 @ 20:27] (3/7)

#7: The Future History of Dwarves [6/17 @ 11:40] (4/9)

#8: Divvying Up and Good byes (buys?) [6/17 @ 12:41] (5/5)

#9: The Parade (of) Homes [6/18 @ 0:09] (5/6)

#10: The Unspoken [6/18 @ 2:28] (4/6)

#11: Parting is Such Sweet Sorrow…. [6/18 @ 18:40] (2/5)

#12: Open Discussion [6/18 @ 18:41] (2/6)

Summary [6/20 @ 11:36] (12/20)

See the 2nd Discussion by Beren IV, June-July 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by Curious, October 2012

 

XIX. The Last Stage

by CelebornsMirror, June 20-25, 2004

Tone of Prose [6/20 @ 15:54] (3/4)

#2 Tone Poem [6/21 @ 12:10] (6/13)

#3 Lullaby Bilbo [6/21 @ 13:59] (3/8)

#4 Necromancer [6/21 @ 15:45] (8/18)

#5 A Walk in the Rain [6/22 @ 13:15] (4/13)

#6 "Gold, Again" [6/22 @ 13:28] (2/6)

#7 Bilbo's Transformation [6/23 @ 14:53] (4/16)

#8 Presumed Dead [6/23 @ 22:48] (6/14)

#9 Bad Rep. [6/24 @ 12:26] (3/5)

#10 Applicability? (with a touch on LOTR fate) [6/24 @ 22:22] (3/3)

#11 Friendships and Desertions [6/24 @ 22:36] (1/2)

#12 Divine Providence and World Impact [6/24 @ 22:59] (3/14)

#13 Tomorrow is Another Day! [6/24 @ 23:12] (3/3)

Summary! [6/25 @ 14:01] (12/14)

Open Forum! (No Text) [6/25 @ 14:02] (1/5)

See the 2nd Discussion by weaver, July 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by sador, November 2012

 

Open Discussion on 'The Hobbit'

as a Free-for-All, June 27-July 1, 2004

Why I lost interest in The Hobbit. <Curious> [6/27 @ 20:50] (8/32)

Apples and Oranges? <drogo_drogo> [6/28 @ 7:16] (11/34)

how do similar books compare? <Curious> [6/29 @ 10:45] (13/40)

Bilbo the Hero <drogo_drogo> [6/29 @ 13:02] (2/7)

What did you learn? <Menelwyn> [7/1 @ 13:51] (9/21)1

 

See the 2nd Discussion as a Free-for-All, August, 2009

See the 3rd Discussion as a Free-for-All, Nov.-Dec. 2012

Home    Previous: Chapters XV-XVII