The Hobbit - Chapters XV - XVII

May 24, 2004 - June 13, 2004

This is the First Discussion - click at right to view the Second and Third Discussions.

Unfortunately, in 2016 the TORn servers began redirecting all hyperlinks to the 'Old Boards' to the current discussion boards. The 'grayed-out' links will be updated if the archival links are ever restored.

Home    Previous: Chapters XI-XIV    Next: Chapters XVIII-XIX

 

XV. The Gathering of the Clouds

by Atlas, May 24-31, 2004

Introduction [5/24 @ 2:53] (2/2)

#1 Consider the birds of the air... [5/24 @ 3:19] (7/12)

#2 Ding! Dong! The dragon's dead... [5/24 @ 3:40] (9/10)

#3 Sending out an SOS... [5/25 @ 3:23] (6/12)

#4 Money. That's what I want. [5/25 @ 3:58] (6/8)

#5 Don't tread on me. [5/26 @ 4:05] (7/7)

#6 What terms do you offer? [5/26 @ 4:35] (6/7)

#7 ...and take those elves with you! [5/27 @ 1:17] (6/14)

#8 All that is gold is not edible... [5/27 @ 3:05] (6/10)

#9 Then it seems we are at an impasse. [5/27 @ 3:06] (4/4)

#10 Open Discussion [5/28 @ 6:01] (8/17)

Summary [5/31 @ 1:59] (12/16)

See the 2nd Discussion by Beren IV, June-July 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by Curious, October 2012

 

XVI. A Thief in the Night

by nerdanel_50, May 31-June 6, 2004

Introduction [5/31 @ 12:33] (1/1)

#1: Playing with the Big Boys [5/31 @ 12:57] (9/24)

#2: Hi-ho, Hi-ho [5/31 @ 13:01] (10/13)

#3: How much watch? [6/1 @ 10:11] (9/15)

#4: Enough Rope [6/1 @ 10:19] (7/7)

#5: The Dwarves' Hobbit [6/2 @ 12:12] (8/9)

#6: What Else Has It Got In Its Pocketses? [6/2 @ 12:14] (7/12)

#7: Belt and Suspenders? [6/3 @ 11:34] (7/23)

#8: He's Back [6/3 @ 11:39] (10/17)

#9: A Thief in the Night [6/4 @ 10:04] (7/16)

#10: Open discussion [6/4 @ 16:45] (2/12)

Summary [6/6 @ 12:42] (14/17)

Afterthought: Don't be hasty [6/6 @ 15:09] (6/9)

See the 2nd Discussion by weaver, July 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by titanium hobbit, October 2012

 

XVII. The Clouds Burst

by Altaira and N.E. Brigand, June 7-13, 2004

<Altaira>

Introduction [6/7 @ 12:55] (1/2)

#1 - What of the Arkenstone of Thrain? [6/7 @ 12:59] (10/19)

#2 - A likely story  [6/7 @ 13:03] (5/20)

#3 - The bewilderment of the treasure [6/7 @ 13:08] (8/21)

<N.E. Brigand>

#4, or #12/3 – Cursed fractions! [6/8 @ 14:15] (7/11)

#5 – Polite words [6/8 @ 14:50] (4/4)

#6 - Western Wind, Eastern Spur [6/8 @ 20:45] (3/7)

#7 – Shoddy Dwarves [6/9 @ 13:57] (4/7)

#8 - Old-Fashioned Language [6/9 @ 14:18] (6/8)

#9 - Over Hill or Under Hill? [6/9 @ 14:34] (4/12)

#10 – Particularly Excellent Fireworks [6/9 @ 14:59] (3/6)

#11 – Gandalf as Bismarck? [6/10 @ 12:14] (5/7)

#12 – Mice! Mice on Wings! [6/10 @ 12:17] (8/10)

#13 – “It Was Very Terrible” [6/10 @ 12:34] (7/14)

#14 – “To Me! To Me!” [6/10 @ 12:40] (5/7)

#15 – Goblins, Goblins Everywhere [6/10 @ 12:43] (4/4)

Interjection: The Elves' chill flame <Beren IV> [6/10 @ 22:53] (1/2)

#16 - Heart Shall Be Bolder [6/11 @ 19:05] (5/6)

#17 - Sailor’s Delight [6/11 @ 20:39] (3/3)

#18 - Open Discussion [6/11 @ 21:47] (4/5)

#18 [19] - Summary [6/13 @ 20:28] (14/17)

See the 2nd Discussion by Tolkien Forever, July 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by dormouse, Oct-Nov 2012

Home    Previous: Chapters XI-XIV    Next: Chapters XVIII-XIX