The Hobbit - Chapters XI - XIV

April 26, 2004 - May 23, 2004

This is the First Discussion - click at right to view the Second and Third Discussions.

Unfortunately, in 2016 the TORn servers began redirecting all hyperlinks to the 'Old Boards' to the current discussion boards. The 'grayed-out' links will be updated if the archival links are ever restored.

Home    Previous: Chapters VIII - X    Next: Chapters XV - XVII

 

XI. On The Doorstep

by NZ Strider, April 26-May 2, 2004

Announcement [4/26 @ 4:35] (5/15)

#1. Toponymy [4/26 @ 14:33] (7/19)

#2. The Lonely Mountain [4/26 @ 14:35] (9/40)

#3: Dale [4/27 @ 5:28] (7/14)

#4: The Source of the Running River [4/27 @ 17:22] (7/29)

#5: Mr. Baggins Reads the ******* Manual [4/27 @ 18:04] (8/11)

#6: Dwarf Doors [4/28 @ 5:32] (8/39)

#7: Mr. Baggins Sits and Thinks [4/28 @ 15:58] (6/27)

#8: The Dwarves’ Recriminations [4/29 @ 6:23] (11/13)

#9: Snails & a Thrush [4/29 @ 17:46] (4/6)

#10: Success at Last! [4/30 @ 2:57] (7/19)

#11: Open Discussion [4/30 @ 3:00] (5/41)

#12: Summary [5/2 @ 2:30] (15/16)

See the 2nd Discussion by ElanorTX, June 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by dernwyn, September 2012

 

XII. Inside Information

by jflower, May 3-7, 2004

#1: Time to earn your keep Mr. Bilbo! [5/3 @ 14:14] (9/14)

#2: Courage, Gold and a little ole Smaug [5/3 @ 22:06] (8/16)

#3: Smaug the Happy . . .nope, I don't think so! [5/4 @ 0:05] (11/27)

#4: Poor little ponies . . . [5/4 @ 18:38] (4/6)

#5: Bilbo the leader? [5/4 @ 21:57] (8/10)

#6: Bilbo's chat with Smaug (part 1) [5/5 @ 12:51] (9/17)

#7: Bilbo's chat with Smaug (part deux) [5/6 @ 0:27] (7/14)

#8: Bilbo the Worrier [5/6 @ 14:05] (7/12)

#9: Thorin's true love! [5/6 @ 14:18] (4/11)

#10: Temper, temper Smaug! [5/7 @ 11:57] (3/12)

#11: Summary and Open Forum [5/7 @ 21:55] (16/30)

See the 2nd Discussion by grammaboodawg, June 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by Morthoron, September 2012

 

XIII. Not At Home

by Arquen, May 9-15, 2004

opening Remarks [5/9 @ 12:04] (6/10)

#1: The sounds of silence [5/10 @ 0:41] (7/10)

#2: A light in dark places. [5/10 @ 13:04] (7/11)

# 3 Take the money and run. [5/10 @ 19:38] (11/113)

#4 Up to Bat [5/11 @ 10:24] (6/8)

#5 The mice will play [& #6 The Return of the King] [5/11 @ 21:57] (6/10)

# 7 The Midas touch (#6 conflated with #5 oops) [5/12 @ 22:35] (3/10)

# 8 Run river run [5/13 @ 12:31] (6/10)

# 9 Cram cookoff [5/13 @ 18:00] (11/24)

# 10 Fade to Black [5/14 @ 12:25] (3/4)

Open Forum [5/14 @ 16:43] (1/7)

summary [5/15 @ 11:46] (14/15)

See the 2nd Discussion by sador, June 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by a Free For All and Modtheow, October 2012

 

XIV. Fire and Water

by Menelwyn, May 16-23, 2004

Intro and Preliminary Question [5/16 @ 14:05] (14/30)

#2: Early Warnings [5/17 @ 8:33] (5/15)

#3: A Bit on Bard [5/17 @ 13:57] (11/16)

#3: Smaug's response [5/18 @ 8:31] (6/6)

#5: Bard and the Thrus [5/18 @ 20:16] (9/16)

#6 The Black Arrow [5/19 @ 8:43] (9/16)

#7: The Debate [5/19 @ 18:38] (6/6)

#8: Human Motives [5/20 @ 18:27] (4/8)

#9: End or a Beginning? [5/20 @ 18:28] (4/4)

#10: Final Exam ;) [5/21 @ 8:37] (3/10)

Open Discussion [5/21 @ 20:21] (3/23)

Summary [5/23 @ 14:40] (13/13)

See the 2nd Discussion as a Free For All, June 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by Modtheow, October 2012

Home    Previous: Chapters VIII - X    Next: Chapters XV - XVII