The Hobbit - Chapters VIII - X

April 4, 2004 - April 25, 2004

This is the First Discussion - click at right to view the Second and Third Discussions.

Unfortunately, in 2016 the TORn servers began redirecting all hyperlinks to the 'Old Boards' to the current discussion boards. The 'grayed-out' links will be updated if the archival links are ever restored.

Home    Previous: Chapters IV - VII    Next: Chapters XI - XIV

 

VIII. Flies and Spiders

by hatster, April 4-10, 2004

I WILL be here to take the chapter discussion [4/4 @ 20:54] (4/6)

First question [4/4 @ 23:10] (12/22)

#2 [4/4 @ 23:16] (11/33)

#3 ( and 4 and heck knows...I think) [4/5 @ 20:07] (7/11)

#4--that path thing, or white deer in the black forest [4/6 @ 7:40] (6/19)

#5--"if they could have kept up their courage" [4/6 @ 19:08] (5/7)

#6 Poor Bombur and jokes [4/7 @ 7:02] (7/9)

#6 [#7] --Expendable hobbits [4/7 @ 7:16] (7/7)

#8--Bigger and biggerer [4/7 @ 7:31] (7/7)

#9 --sweet shades of Shelob and Sting [4/7 @ 7:55] (9/17)

#10--the tangled webs woven [4/7 @ 21:51] (6/9)

#11 -- Chatty little things, aren't they? [4/7 @ 22:28] (5/10)

#12 [4/8 @ 7:48] (5/20)

#13--Where is Thorin? [4/8 @ 7:59] (8/19)

#14--Games in Middle-earth [4/8 @ 18:51] (6/16)

#15--the tease [4/8 @ 19:14] (5/6)

#16-- Bilbo as played by Errol Flynn [4/9 @ 12:06] (7/13)

#17--Leaders and Rings [4/9 @ 12:35] (8/11)

#18--Cave dwellers [4/9 @ 23:09] (7/8)

#19--about that Path again [4/9 @ 23:29] (4/13)

#20 --Whew! it's your turn now! [4/9 @ 23:32] (6/40)

Summary [4/10 @ 21:31] (16/16)

 

See the 2nd Discussion by Dreamdeer, May 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by N.E. Brigand, Aug-Sept 2012

 

IX. Barrels Out of Bond

by drogo_drogo, April 11-18, 2004

Intro [4/11 @ 15:37] (6/6)

1: The Elvenking’ Gate [4/12 @ 6:48] (7/24)

2: So Dad, Where’s the Dreamy Son of Yours? :-) [4/12 @ 6:53] (9/17)

3: Magic Doors and Mind Your Manners [4/12 @ 14:50] (5/11)

4: Bilbo on the Prowl [4/13 @ 11:01] (6/11)

5: “Burgling the Same House Day After Day” [4/13 @ 11:03] (6/24)

6: Mirkwood Trade Relations and Elven Wine Connoisseurs [4/13 @ 19:44] (5/12)

7: The Butler, The Chief, and Dorwinion too [4/14 @ 8:02] (4/4)

8: The Great Escape [4/14 @ 8:03] (5/5)

9: Yes, More Songs [4/14 @ 8:08] (3/15)

Bonus Question--How Good is the Plan? [4/14 @ 21:12] (10/19)

Why did the Elvenking have dungeons? <Curious> [4/15 @ 17:01] (12/32)

Drunken Elves <SlowLil'Hobbit> [4/16 @ 15:26] (4/5)

Last Questions at Last [4/16 @ 19:35] (8/12)

Open Barrels o' Fun [4/17 @ 8:31] (3/22)

Closing the Barrel Lid on the Week [4/18 @ 8:58] (10/12)

One more question about the last two chapters. <Curious> [4/20 @ 7:24] (3/6)

See the 2nd Discussion by Kelvarhin, May 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by dormouse, September 2012

 

X. A Warm Welcome

by Draupne, April 19-25, 2004

Why there won't happen much today [4/19 @ 8:50] (4/7)

#2 [4/20 @ 5:39] (8/36)

#3 [4/20 @ 7:43] (8/19)

#4 [4/21 @ 9:44] (4/11)

#5 [4/21 @ 10:04] (6/6)

#6 [4/21 @ 10:16] (3/12)

#7 [4/23 @ 8:07] (5/5)

#8 [4/23 @ 9:11] (6/12)

Some comments on "A Warm Welcome":<Curious> [4/25 @ 19:48] (4/13)

 

See the 2nd Discussion by Laerasëa, May 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by telain, September 2012

Home    Previous: Chapters IV - VII    Next: Chapters XI - XIV