The Hobbit - Chapters IV - VII

March 8, 2004 - April 2, 2004

This is the First Discussion - click at right to view the Second and Third Discussions.

Unfortunately, in 2016 the TORn servers began redirecting all hyperlinks to the 'Old Boards' to the current discussion boards. The 'grayed-out' links will be updated if the archival links are ever restored.

Home    Previous: Chapters I - III    Next: Chapters VIII - X

 

IV. Over Hill and Under Hill

by Altaira, March 8-13, 2004

#1: One wrong turn…. [3/8 @ 16:03] (8/10)

#2: The Mountain Path [3/8 @ 16:38] (9/11)

#3: A Snail’s Pace [3/9 @ 15:38] (7/14)

#4: Thunder and Lightning [3/9 @ 16:58] (4/6)

#5: Stone Giants! [3/9 @ 17:10] (11/35)

#6: Shelter from the Storm [3/11 @ 1:48] (6/10)

#7: Goblins I – Faces only their Mothers Could Love [3/11 @ 14:20] (16/24)

#8: Goblins II – Goblin Songs [3/11 @ 15:27] (8/15)

#9: Goblin Society [3/11 @ 16:25] (9/14)

#10 – Biter and Beater [3/13 @ 14:28] (6/14)

Open Discussion [3/13 @ 14:29] (3/10)

#11: Bilbo – Hero or Coward so Far? (Summary) [3/13 @ 20:22] (12/14)

See the 2nd Discussion by Arwen's Daughter, April 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by One Ringer, July-August 2012

 

V. Riddles in the Dark

by Entmaiden, March 15-21, 2004

#I. Setting the scene [3/15 @ 0:21] (9/13)

#II. Finding the Ring [3/15 @ 12:23] (11/20)

#III. The Shining Sword [3/15 @ 14:33] (14/32)

#IV. Hobbity traits [3/16 @ 10:13] (8/9)

#V. Tunnels [3/16 @ 10:15] (10/12)

#VI. Ugh! Icy cold [3/16 @ 16:13] (8/13)

#VII. Our first look at Gollum [3/16 @ 16:23] (7/9)

#VIII. Bilbo meets Gollum [3/17 @ 9:41] (8/18)

#IX. Gollum’s friends [3/17 @ 9:44] (6/6)

#X. The Prize [3/17 @ 16:04] (12/12)

#XI. The Authorities [3/17 @ 16:11] (9/10)

#XII. Riddle me this [3/17 @ 16:14] (3/15)

#XIII. Losing the Precious [3/18 @ 10:07] (5/6)

#XIV Flags on the Field [3/18 @ 10:09] (3/3)

#XV. Time to go! [3/18 @ 19:20] (5/13)

#XVI. The Ring takes a new master [3/19 @ 10:13] (9/30)

#XVII. Escape [3/19 @ 10:14] (7/17)

#XVIII. Alternate ending to the Riddle Game [3/19 @ 17:26] (2/11)

#XIX: Open Discussion [3/19 @ 17:27] (2/20)

Summary [3/21 @ 13:51] (12/13)

See the 2nd Discussion by Morthoron, April 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by squire, August 2012

 

VI. Out of the Frying-Pan into the Fire

by Entmaiden, March 22-26, 2004

Opening Remarks [3/22 @ 15:32] (4/6)

Bilbo (Part 1) [3/22 @ 15:51] (13/13)

Bilbo (Part 2) [3/22 @ 17:52] (6/9)

Bilbo (Part 3) [3/23 @ 9:59] (8/11)

Gandalf (Part 1) [3/23 @ 13:04] (6/6)

Gandalf (Part 2) [3/23 @ 18:29] (3/3)

Gandalf (Part 3) [3/24 @ 9:08] (5/7)

The Dwarves (Part 1) [3/24 @ 16:58] (7/11)

The Dwarves (Part 2) [3/24 @ 17:00] (5/5)

The Location [3/25 @ 9:56] (5/10)

The Wargs and the Goblins (Part 1) [3/25 @ 10:01] (3/3)

The Wargs and the Goblins (Part 2) [3/25 @ 18:30] (6/6)

The Eagles [3/26 @ 8:18] (5/5)

Open Discussion [3/26 @ 8:23] (4/11)

Summary [3/28 @ 19:35] (12/12)

See the 2nd Discussion by batik, April-May 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by sador, August 2012

 

VII. Queer Lodgings

by Daughter of Nienna, March 28-April 2, 2004

#0: Introduction [3/28 @ 7:57] (3/5)

# 1: Woke Up with the Early Sun in his Eyes [3/29 @ 2:16] (9/25)

#2: Hobbits and Rabbits [3/29 @ 3:23] (9/19)

# 3: The Flight [3/29 @ 3:57] (5/11)

# 4: Lord of the Eagles [3/29 @ 4:54] (4/13)

#5: On the Carrock [3/29 @ 14:50] (5/8)

#6: Mercy! If Giving of Information is the Cure for Inquisitiveness [3/29 @ 20:04] (4/6)

#7: Beorn, part-2: The Beornings [3/30 @ 2:18] (4/6)

#8-a: Beorn, part 1-a: Who is Beorn? [3/30 @ 3:57] (3/10)

#8-b: Beorn, part 2: Who is Beorn? – Cont. [3/30 @ 4:04] (6/10)

#9: Beorn, part 3: Enchantment [3/30 @ 4:24] (5/7)

#10: Ripe Acorns [3/30 @ 17:40] (3/3)

#11: Size in Beorn’s world [3/30 @ 18:30] (2/3)

#12: Missing Buttons [3/30 @ 18:35] (7/9)

#13: Beorn’s Hall [3/31 @ 0:30] (3/7)

#14: Gandalf’s Tale / Open Forum [3/31 @ 0:34] (2/3)

#15: Gandalf’s Plan [3/31 @ 0:36] (2/2)

#16: Snow-white Sheep and the Thirteen Dwarves [3/31 @ 13:10] (4/4)

#17: Tales and Magic [3/31 @ 13:12] (3/3)

#18: Dwarves’ Song [3/31 @ 13:16] (5/5)

#19: Heed no Nightly Noises [3/31 @ 15:16] (4/4)

#20: Smoke Rings and Clotted Cream [3/31 @ 22:21] (5/5)

#21: Gandalf the Spy [3/31 @ 22:23] (3/4)

#22: Dreams and Dancing Bears [3/31 @ 22:33] (2/4)

#23: Killed the Great Goblin! [4/1 @ 6:06] (2/7)

#24: Mirkwood [4/1 @ 6:44] (5/5)

#25: Howl of Hunting Wolves [4/1 @ 14:57] (4/5)

#26: Farewell to Gandalf [4/1 @ 15:42] (5/5)

#27: No Safe Paths [4/1 @ 22:33] (2/5)

#28: Final Beorn Questions [4/1 @ 22:36] (3/9)

#29: Final Chapter Questions [4/1 @ 22:37] (4/6)

#30: Open Forum (No Text - Link Inside) [4/2 @ 14:12] (4/14)

#31: Summary [4/2 @ 14:14] (10/28)

See the 2nd Discussion by Elven, May 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by Pryderi, August 2012

Home    Previous: Chapters I - III    Next: Chapters VIII - X