The Hobbit - Chapters I - III

February 16, 2004 - March 8, 2004

This is the First Discussion - click at right to view the Second and Third Discussions.

Unfortunately, in 2016 the TORn servers began redirecting all hyperlinks to the 'Old Boards' to the current discussion boards. The 'grayed-out' links will be updated if the archival links are ever restored.

Home    Next: Chapters IV - VII

 

I. An Unexpected Party

by Inferno, February 16-20, 2004

In the Beginning. [2/16 @ 13:01] (19/46)

What's in a name? [2/16 @ 13:15] (18/28)

Teatime [2/16 @ 13:31] (14/27)

A gaggle of geese, a pride of lions, a trickle of Dwarves? [2/16 @ 13:38] (15/23)

Thorin [2/17 @ 14:19] (11/26)

Gandalf [2/17 @ 14:19] (10/37)

Bilbo, a Baggins and Took. Oh My! [2/17 @ 14:20] (10/38)

Quotable Quotes [2/18 @ 16:12] (8/11)

Two poems, a cursory look. [2/18 @ 16:13] (4/7)

"Chip the Glasses", in great detail. [2/18 @ 16:14] (4/11)

"Far over the misty mountains", and in-depth look. [2/18 @ 16:15] (8/32)

All about Golf [2/19 @ 12:38] (11/29)

Open Discussion. [2/19 @ 12:39] (16/98)

Le' me esplain. No. That woul' take to long. Le' me sum up. [2/20 @ 13:29] (22/26)

See the 2nd Discussion by squire, March 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by Hamfast Gamgee, July 2012

 

II. Roast Mutton

by Curious, February 22-29, 2004

Preliminary Remarks [2/22 @ 9:44] (3/11)

#1: Roast Mutton? [2/22 @ 9:55] (16/48)

#2: Under the Mantle Clock [2/22 @ 13:13] (15/25)

#3: The Note [2/22 @ 22:26] (15/23)

#4: Ten Minutes [2/23 @ 6:03] (12/22)

#5: Evil-looking Castles [2/23 @ 13:09] (13/34)

#6: Foul Weather [2/23 @ 16:50] (12/27)

#7: Mischief in the Fire [2/23 @ 21:03] (9/19)

#8: Moving Silently [2/24 @ 1:26] (10/26)

#9: Trolls [2/24 @ 10:56] (12/27)

#10: What Bilbo Had Read [2/24 @ 10:57] (13/26)

#11: A Talking Purse [2/25 @ 7:54] (10/14)

#12: Saved by a Gorgeous Row [2/25 @ 7:56] (8/14)

#13: Twelve Dwarves Caught [2/25 @ 16:52] (4/5)

#14: Fighting Dwarves [2/25 @ 16:53] (7/13)

#15: Thorin Caught, Gandalf Returns [2/25 @ 23:25] (4/4)

#16: Stoned Trolls [2/26 @ 5:33] (10/22)

#17: Fool of a Baggins [2/26 @ 5:34] (6/12)

#18: Good Blades [2/26 @ 18:59] (8/11)

#19: Buried Treasure [2/26 @ 20:21] (8/10)

#20: Elves, and the Chapter as a Whole [2/27 @ 4:18] (10/14)

#21: The Chapter as Part of a Novel [2/27 @ 4:57] (7/13)

#22: Looking Back on the Week. [2/27 @ 15:53] (6/16)

#23: Summary [2/29 @ 8:51] (17/20)

See the 2nd Discussion by Finding Frodo, March-April 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by SirDennisC, July 2012

 

III. A Short Rest

by Doorwarden of Theoden, March 1-8, 2004

#1: No Mapquest in Middle Earth [3/1 @ 12:04] (8/12)

#2: Rivendell and environs [3/1 @ 20:09] (8/21)

#3: The Elves' song [3/2 @ 19:07] (7/19)

#4: So where did the pretentious elves go? [3/2 @ 19:20] (11/15)

#5: Intrigue in Imladris [3/3 @ 18:45] (4/12)

#6: Elrond [3/3 @ 18:56] (11/13)

#7: The Swords [3/5 @ 12:18] (7/7)

#8: Moon-letters [3/5 @ 12:47] (5/9)

#9: What the Moon-letters said [3/6 @ 11:32] (4/8)

Open Discussion [3/6 @ 19:55] (4/7)

Thank you, Doorwarden of Theoden, for leading last week's discussion! <Curious> [3/8 @ 12:50] (12/12)

See the 2nd Discussion by Menelwyn, April 2009

See the 3rd Discussion by Finding Frodo, July 2012

Home    Next: Chapters IV - VII